
As the politicians continue to hammer out the details of the $700 billion bailout package and the Dow perfects its bungee-jumping abilities, my friends and neighbors are wondering how they’ll pay this winter’s heating bills and watching their kids’ 529 college savings plans shrivel up.
America’s economic pain has taken center stage in the race for the White House. Sen. Barack Obama recently suggested that we should be able to withdraw up to 15%, or as much as $10,000, of our IRA or 401(k) without getting slapped with the 10% IRS tax penalty for early withdrawal before reaching 59 years, six months. The ability to tap these retirement funds would extend through 2009 for families who may be forced to make some difficult, and very painful, financial decisions.
While the goal behind Obama’s idea is laudable, the idea’s a bad one, in my opinion, for any but those who are backed into a corner with no other options.
Both IRAs and 401(k) plans were created by Congress (in 1974 and 1980, respectively) to help families save for retirement. Both plans are very popular because you can make pre-tax contributions in which both the principal and interest compound tax-free until you’re ready to withdraw the money in retirement. This allows your money to grow much faster than if it were subject to income taxes year after year.
Under current law, the 10% tax penalty is waived for individuals who can prove hardships (such as excessive medical expenses) or for first-time homebuyers. Obama’s proposal would eliminate the need to demonstrate hardship and let anyone withdraw those funds, but only up to $10,000. Still, this would allow people to withdraw 30% of investments earmarked for retirement during the next 15 months.
Automatic contributions regularly withdrawn from your paychecks have probably fattened up your 401(k) quite nicely during the long-running bull market. But while it’s awfully tempting to dip into those future reserves for today’s needs, resist the temptation.
Here’s why. Even with the waiver of the 10% IRS tax penalty, withdrawals would still be subject to a 20% federal income tax. And selling mutual funds or stocks now, with the stock market in a nosedive, means you’ll be further penalized for having the worst possible timing. The closer you are to retirement, the fewer years you’ll have to rebuild your retirement nest egg.
If you’re working now, that means you still have an opportunity to get through this recession intact, by taking on a second job if you have to, restructuring your budget or pruning household expenses. But once you get into your 60s or 70s, you might not have the option of continuing to work (if you wanted or needed to), due to unforeseen health problems. Once retired, you’ll depend on the proverbial three-legged stool to get by ⎯ personal savings, Social Security and, if you’re lucky, a pension. Don’t risk a less-than-comfortable retirement if, by exploring all of your other options today, you can find a way to make it through these tough times.